Rock Paper Shotgun throws a fit over Bethesda's New Review Copy policy

Within the news of "Gaming Journalism" where unethical practices are the normality in which reviewers commonly black mail developers at the mercy of not only their audience but their input and expanding audience. Now before you gut me and hang me just hear me out, I have worked on various titles in the past and have seen this first hand...

The past: 

You see much like a site like this can grow so can sites like Rock Paper Shotgun's but they are a "Real Gaming News Journalist" you say, but oh lets take a look at their track record, well it is not kotaku bad but it has been involved with many underhanded misleading reviews with EXPOSED back door processes such as the Zoey quin with nathan grayson case, he was also with kotaku And again Nathan Grayson soon after was exposed again, and again, and again for unethical practices, Including reviewing a game made by a former colleague without mentioning it ever once. Now this isn't as bad as the Zoey Quin case but I thought I would mention it along with the pro-Anita propaganda they were pushing out and trying to force feed all of us gamers trying to tell us we are sexist for enjoying games and manufacturing evidence to do so.

But that is not what I really wanted to talk about,

What I really want to talk about:

On a steam update post for fallout 4 & skyrim they posted about dishonored 2 in how they demanded a review copy right now,

They are mad over this new policy that enables them to force these developers to send them stuff for free, and they are upset because the new policy for review copies to be given out a day before release.

Their excuse on how this is anti-consumerism is because it is anti-them, they don't want to wait for the game to release before they start tearing it a new one so bethesda got tired of superiority complex and told them to wait to review it, forcing reviewers to actually wait on getting a review copy to make sure they really want to rather than shovel out the copy paste crap they have been pulling for the last decade or two.

When a reviewer, reviews a game it should be meaningful as this is someones very very very hard work, and shouldn't be taken so lightly . Their excuse for this move is "OH BAD GAMES DON'T BUY BECAUSE WE CAN'T GET MONEY OFF THE HYPE OF THE GAME AND MANUFACTURE HYPE FOR OUR SITES AND GAIN MORE MONEY THAT WAY.".

It is like if you were to demand a video out of them right now as soon as they get 3/4 the way through the process of making it, so you can judge that.

The Advertising Biased Practice:

Commonly you will notice that their ads much like gamestop, IGN, and kotaqu all are games they all push forward this money to be "advertised" and in doing so receive a "positive review", this is common practice amoungst the elites. Some as going far to say pay for advertising or we will review your game badily.

Rock Paper Shotgun pushes for advertising with them, keep in mind they also use google adsense advertising on top of this and want games advertised on their site, meaning they more than likely could review a game that goes through their advertising biasedily because they shelled out the money to push their products already.

The Blackmail:

Not saying Rock Paper Shotgun has done this but many have demanded goodies special editions over hundreds or thousands of dollars in money or gifts.  Now call me crazy for thinking this as of blackmail practice but with my android development experience I have seen this first hand, and with my experience with working with other studios for free keep in mind.

It works two ways, those whom auto-comply with this,  those whom benefit from this practice being the norm, and those whom get trashed through the mud.

Wealthy companies like Bethesda, EA, and Activision can afford to shell out ever last cent advertising their games and doing it on every major "Gaming news outlet" and still have money left over to buy out every small company all at the same time. So this practice benefits them as it disallows for smaller indie developers to pay for their titles to be pushed on platforms via advertising and their games commonly get dragged through the mud if they can not afford any at all.

Ethical issues with all this and conclusion:

Now what is ethically wrong with all this practice of demanding review copies and demanding goodies. Well it is very well a old practice at that, unpaid for service with extremely high standards even before the product is well close to being actually finished and judging it as if it were.

Meaning the more free stuff thrown at them the more they will likely review positively regardless of quality. Meaning even the fact they are given the game will cause them to biasedily favor it over a game they had to purchase. Meaning you are not getting a honest review out of them, if you had to pay for it and they didn't.

But the review sites such as Rock Paper Shotgun have been greedy over the years finding their involvement in nearly every damn scandle there is, so is black mail really out of the question of their involvement? They could be demanding they buy adspace, they could be demanding goodies, they could be demanding a paid for review without ever once saying it is to the base consumer as well.

But we are not here to burn them by the steak now, their demands for earily access review copies is just down right out of the question, reviewers should wait, it isn't the gamers waiting like they try to pass off, it is the reviewers who are attempting to be the first ones to get in on every cash cow by targeting what is popular and trying to be the first one to the case if they are late they commonly copy paste reword practice just to grab a few views. Hence why there is little to no difference from the first review that comes out and the last with certain sites, Rock Paper Shotgun included in all that.

This practice is "Anti-"Corruption in gaming news Journalism and don't let the fools at Rock Paper Shotgun tell you any differently, that is why they are pissed. Honestly if they had to buy every game their practices would be forced to change, and this unethical give them shit for good review would be dead in the water as it should be.

No comments :

Post a Comment

Please be kind to others, and my self.

Rss Feed

Undeadbobop's blogs

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

My Other Blogs


I heart FeedBurner


construct 2 Nintendo game review ouya wiiu windows android linux pc games google Chrome Microsoft free mac web development scirra Dreamout chrome os controller steam valve Sega chromebook play controls programming youtube game development help #nintendo 2d Apple DRM Wii store template unity Dream chrome book gaming update video 3d GNU/Linux How to SEO bus construct custom driver gamepad menu music out rush tutorial video games HTML5 Nintendo Switch bad cheap console experience javascript online software xbox 360 Iphone Pokemon go Switch art assets code engine font gamejolt halflife iOS os raspberry pi retroarch sale sonic sound sprite support website Genesis Mario Saturn adventure amazon app book chromeos clone css down effects emulation fix gamestop internet level life nes opengl phone problems sega genesis source spritefonts spriter work 3ds Fishing Game development companies in detroit Mario Kart Megadrive Micro-transactions Playstation Scam Sega Saturn Sony Sucks Ubuntu acer ad adv advance bugs computer counter strike global offensive delay drawing emulator example free software gimp java kongregate modeling network nvidia pack platformer project ripoff security snes starter system undeadbobop windows 8 $oft 2014 Beginner C# Corsair DLC Developers Doom Dreamcast Game review NX Photoshop Retropi Sega Genesis Ultimate Portable Game Player Things USA Virtual abuse acer 11 ads adv menu advertisement application apps arcade atari best bing blog blue bobop c++ coin construct 3 construct2 counter strike crash csgo design develop directx email face faceplate fail fps functions game development tools give away glitches gnu googleplay graphics hackers halflife 3 halo issues itch.io libretro lies link low make maps menus minecraft money movie news of optimization options paint patch php plate pokemon pool pro retropie screw sounds summer terrible tf2 tools top trirectimo up usb valve editor hammer virtual console voice vs webhosting wireless worst xbox 360 xml zelda 1 2 3 submit pro 2 25th Anniversary 5 AI America C# XNA Gamestudio CD Call of Duty Cast Comparison Controller Pro Controller Pro U Copy DVD Digital Direct Discs Documentations Dragon Drive East Detroit Eastpointe Eshop Facebook GBA Golden HTML ID IT Marker Microshaft Microsoft store in michigan Moore Mupen64 Nights Old PS2 Personal Peter RSS Record RollApp Samsung Screenshots Secret Skateboard Sprite font Steam controller Super Mario TV Tech VR review WoW XBL Zelda breath of wild abandon abandonware ad free adsense advance menu system advertisers affordable alternative amd angry art work assault audio away balls bfxr block blogger bo's breaks brick bride bug build bundle bungie bus driver 2d experience rush capture card cards cat character cheaters choice chrome web browser club color command commercial connect construct 2 gaming engine contest convict convict gaming corruption cost counterstrike create crush dead demo depression descriptions done download e3 easy education electric electronic emulation station emulators ethics event evil exploit family features feed flash fonts fraud fx galaxy game development companies game development companies in michigan game engines gameplay gaming assets get gif give google chrome greed guide half halflife 2 head hl2 honest hosting image images improves is issue item items jam jolicloud keyboard kick kickstarter kitten kitty lag lan learning liars lock making manager map menu system micro milkshape 3d misleading mobile mods monogame multiplayer netplay networking new noncommercial not odd off one pewdiepie pie players playing plugins port program quake quick random raspbian red remote require rewards rip road save saving screen screenshot script sdl search sega dreamcast server settings site skate skeleton small snapshot song sprite sheet spyware steam box steam gamepad steam os steamos strike team tegra templates terrorists text tic tac toe to tool top 10 touch tree unreal use useless version video game videogame vidme virus ware web server webgl webstorage webstore wedding world xbone xbox one xboxdone xboxone zombies #e3 10 10 ways 200 2015 2600 3.14 343 3:4 ratio 3DTin 3d modeling 5 nights 64 7 7th guest 8 90 API ARM AT&T ATOM ATT AVGN Ace Adriano AlphaOmegaSin Amiibo Android disable ads in games Animation Backlinks Balmer Batdan Bernie Bethesda's New Review Copy Policy Bill Blackjack Blackmail Bluetooth Boarding Bob Ross Bros Bully C++. directx Cities Classic Computers Consoles Cool Corel Corruption in gaming news journalism Creators Cyanara DDOS DMCA DMZ DNS Deluxe Detroit Dogs EA EULA Eco Edge gamepad Edition Emio Encore F.E.A.R. FCC Facebook account hijack Fanboy Feeds Feminism First person shooter Flowcharts Footage GPL GamePop Gamer Gamestick Gates Gear VR Genesis Ultimate Portable Game Player God Gold Grammar HD HDMI HP HTC Vive Halo 2 Halo 2 Anniversary Halo Reach Halo legends Humble Bundle ICEY ID Tech IDE IE IGN IOS 9 ISP Impact Impressions Install Irate Irategamer Jaden smith Japanese Jet pack Jim Kainy Kart Kim Jong-un Knuckles Kotaqu LG LGBT Las Vegas Last Launch Lenovo Library Linksys Lucid Lycoming mall Mad Mad over Mario Galaxy Mario kart 8 deluxe Mario odyssey Marker sprite font Metro Michigan Microsoft wordpress Monodevelopment Moon Mortal Kombat Mote Movies Mysterious NSA Navel Nes classic Next Nintendo 64 North Korea November OC OS X OSX Ocarina Ohio Omega On off switch Onedrive Painter Painting Paradise Paths Performance Pokken tournament Pokken tournament Pikachi controller Privacy Badger Projared Promotion Pygames Pyshell Python Python Fiddle RPG Rage Razer Forge TC Reach Released Remix Retrobit Retroduo Retrogen ReviewTechUSA Rock Rock Paper Shotgun Rockstar Roseville SMM SQL SWF SWJ Scholarship Shaft Ship Sin SkyDrive Smash Sonic 3d blast Star Starling Steven Stolar Sun Super Mario Maker Super Smash Bros Tails miles Text adventure The Interview The Letter Tony Hawk Total Media Town TreeFall Studios Treehouse Tuner Twitch UML Ubisoft VBA VLC Valor Vegas Vengeance Video game art Visio Watch Watchdogs Wino WoW! Woofle XBLA Zilla accessories accounts achievements acting adapter adblock add on admin adreno airplane algorithms alone alpha always amazing amazon app store animal animate animated animations anime app developer in detroit Michigan app development appegg appspotr arch array ashleey asus atgames attack audience auto back back links background badges bag bags ball ballz bandicoot banks bar base basic basics basketball battery battle. DLC. link bayonetta beating bed bgoat big bios bioshock birds birthday bit bites black blackberry blacklist blade blast blender blockstorm bloodmoon blur bo boom bored borkin button boxes boy bricks broke broken brotherhood browser bsd buck bucks buggy bust buy c++. html c64 cable can can't canceled candy capcom car care caret-t caster cb3-111 cereal chair challenges change cheating checking chimp chimpmail chrome cast chromebooke chromecast app clara clara.io classical clearance client closure compiler cloud applications cloud computing cocoonjs code envy coding college colour comedy comments community compatibility competitive market compiler complaints complete roms list computer AI connect 4 connecting cons constroller construct 2 gaming engine plugin construct 2 holiday plugin construct 2 plugin construct 2 time and date plugin content costume couch counter counter strike condition zero counter terrorists court cpu crafting crap crazy crd creating creation creativity credit crossing crusher ctf cubes cue curse cursor customization templates cylinders daniel date object dbz deathmatch dell demonetization desert desktop desura develoming developing development kit dial dialup died difficult dig disabilities discontinued dishonest disney do doesn't work dollar dos downfall drag dragonball dreams drug store ds duckduckgo dug dumb dumbphone dust button easter egg eastside ebaulms edge email list eminem emu end engines enlightenment entertainment environment episodes essential ethical practices ever exclusive expand expired site exporting eyes fall fallout fallout 4 famous fan art fast fear fees feminist file fill fire firecore firefox firefox marketplace firefox os firewall firm firmware first five flac flaw flickr food football for forget forgotten domain fortress fox frame frame rate framework freddy's free money free to play freeware fried friend friendship fsf full fullscreen fun gambling game asset pack game list game maker gameboy gamegear gameinformer gamemaker gamers gaming easter eggs gaming engine garrys mod gas gears geek gender glitch glove go good goofed google play google+ gore gorescript gpu grand grandtheft auto gray greedy green grey grid groom gta guestbook gunners h2100 hacking halflive handheld hard hardware harmony hawk headphones headset hedgehog hell hexen highschool highscore hijack hl1 holidays home homebrew homicide hook hori gamepad hotel hotmail humble humor hyperkin hypermart illegal index color indie indiedb industries industry information informer inn input input device insomnia instinct institute instructors intel intel vs amd intentional internet explorer internet radio interview introduction ion ip ip address irish iron island isometric iwork jack james jelly jif jiggly puff jiminquestion job joint joke jokes journalism joytokey js k70 key keystation killed killstreak kingdom hearts kryo land lash law legacy collection legal length lerp liar lib GDX light lilly lithium live load local locked logic logmein lonely loop lost temple text adventure low end lowest market ludei lynx machine macomb community college macombacon mail mail chimp make money fast makefile maker manifest mapping market market share marketing marriage married mass email subscription service master mechanical media megaman melody meow microsd microusb midi mii miitomo mike mike v mind mini mini game minimum wage minish cap misleads moddb modding mode models mogotxt moltres monetize monitziation montization monzilla mouse murder musial mussels mystic n64 nba need nerd net netlink newgrounds nexon nfl nitch no notepad++ now nurse nwjs nyan o'reilly odk office offline oggenc2 oh operation out of order out of service out there overscan p2p p2w pad paid pandora panic papagayo paper weight parody party pause pay peer peerblock pewdie phishing phones photo pi piano picture pin pink pixel art plagiarism plants plants vs zombies plastic platinum player playzool please plus pngcrush pngnqi pngout poke balls poker pokestops pool table popular populate portable posts power practice practive pre-order premade presentation preview price private processors promises promote provider ps1 ps3 ps4 public purple qlife qualcomm quest rack radio raffle ram rant rare rate razer recommend recording red cherry redit remove renaissance repair representation resources rest retirement retrode retron 5 retry rigging ripper river roads rolfe rom roms routing saga same score screen sharing screencastify scroogle scum seamless seed sega master system sequel servers service set setup seven card shapes share this shareware sharing shield shit shockwave shooter shop shot signs simple slavery sleep slip slumber smart smartboy smo snapdragon social media soda solitions sparks sparky spartan specialized spell check spelling spheres spoiler free spotify spyro stakes steam link sterling steve scott stop storm strategy game strategy guide stream streaming stud studio studios styles subscribe success super super mario maker bugs super mutants sync systems table tac tags tamagotchi target target marketing tax taxes teachers teaching team fortress 2 crafting teams temple run temple run 2 testing textbase texture packer the king's league odyssey the world theft this thoughts thunder tic tile tilemap time time date tin titles toe tony top 5 topic matter torque touchpad toys trading travel traveling trees tube understanding news feeds unearthing unethical bots union unusual usb 3.0 usb y users vc view views villager vimeo vine vintage virtual reality volume voxel wall wallet wan wave wayback web assembly web design web server ultimate webmaster websites websitesubmit what is my ip white will Smith wired word wordpress workaround workshop xbox gamepad xeno xenoblade xhml xl xna you yourself zapdose zip zombie zombie panic zombie panic source